Judges IRC Logs/Scoring!
Braden -
(1:02:00 PM) Braden2:
(1:07:39 PM) Braden2: Ok
(1:07:42 PM) Braden2: Got it
(1:07:46 PM) Braden2: How do you want me to give it to you?
(1:07:49 PM) Braden2: Aggregate scores?
(1:07:51 PM) Braden2: or breakdowns?
(1:07:54 PM) Cata|Vanette: breakdowns
(1:08:49 PM) Braden2: #1=25,O=9,T=9,OA=7
(1:09:07 PM) Braden2: #2=28,O=9,T=10,OA=9
(1:09:23 PM) Braden2: #3=26,O=9,T=9,OA=8
(1:09:37 PM) Braden2: #4=30,O=10,T=10,OA=10
(1:09:52 PM) Braden2: #5=26,O=9,T=10,OA=7
(1:09:58 PM) Braden2: There it is
(1:10:11 PM) Cata|Vanette: thanks
a ton
KUB -
(12:11:16 PM) Cata|Vanette: House #1
(12:11:17 PM) Cata|Vanette:
http://i45.tinypic.com/10cw8zs.jpg
(12:14:45 PM) KUB|WAR: Theme: 9 Originality: 7 Overall: 8
(12:15:19 PM) Cata|Vanette: house #2
(12:17:58 PM) KUB|WAR: 7 / 7 / 7 - nothing really *pops out* at me but the bed looks 'cute of UO' w/ that bedroll ... nice deco overall but pretty plain
(12:18:42 PM) Cata|Vanette: this is a two part
(12:18:43 PM) Cata|Vanette: #3
(12:22:14 PM) KUB|WAR: 6 / 6 / 6 - nothing at all jumps out
(12:25:51 PM) Cata|Vanette: #4
http://img695.imageshack.us/img695/8795/kitchenv.jpg
(12:26:57 PM) KUB|WAR: man that's pretty sweet
(12:28:20 PM) KUB|WAR: 9 / 8 / 9 - I really like the overall theme and flow of it ... the Frontroom portraits w/ the shade & candles look sweet
(12:28:27 PM) Cata|Vanette: and #5
(12:28:31 PM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img693.imageshack.us/img693/1078 ... yjcoq7.jpg
(12:28:57 PM) KUB|WAR: whoa
(12:29:53 PM) KUB|WAR: torture table thing is something I don't recall having ever seen
(12:30:21 PM) KUB|WAR: and the "pizza oven setup" is pretty tight, as well as the meatgrinder area/flour mills
(12:31:11 PM) KUB|WAR: 10 / 9 / 9.5 (!?)
(12:31:17 PM) KUB|WAR: Dunno if that .5 is acceptable
(12:31:21 PM) Cata|Vanette: uhh
(12:31:23 PM) Cata|Vanette: it'll work
(12:31:26 PM) KUB|WAR: but I wanted to distinguish
(12:31:33 PM) KUB|WAR: that it was better than the 9 of the last one
(12:31:35 PM) KUB|WAR: =(
Platypus -
(11:35:02 AM) Cata|Vanette: here!
(11:35:04 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://i45.tinypic.com/10cw8zs.jpg
(11:39:26 AM) platypus: ya, i think its a winery
(11:39:55 AM) platypus: Theme: 3, Originality: 2, Overall Appeal: 4
(11:35:08 AM) Cata|Vanette: Needs to be judged based on uh
(11:35:17 AM) Cata|Vanette: Theme, Originality, and a third cat that we're coming up with now
(11:35:18 AM) Cata|Vanette: 1- 10
(11:40:07 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://sites.google.com/site/khaaans/Humble_Abode.png
(11:40:08 AM) Cata|Vanette: next one
(11:40:52 AM) platypus: give me a minute, grabbing soda
(11:40:56 AM) Cata|Vanette: np np
(11:42:27 AM) platypus: Theme: 7, Originality: 7, Overall Appeal: 9 (not that inventive of dector, but looks really great)
(11:42:32 AM) platypus: *decor
(11:43:31 AM) platypus: how many are there total? i havent looked at that thread in like a week
(11:46:45 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v610/ ... stairs.jpg
(11:46:49 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v610/ ... stairs.jpg
(11:46:51 AM) platypus: isnt it on the forum page?
(11:47:11 AM) Cata|Vanette: the owner of it is gonna reupload it
(11:48:21 AM) platypus: okay, last one you sent:
(11:49:18 AM) platypus: Theme: 5, Originality: 9, Overall Appeal: 7 (downstairs looks great! i love the couch, sink and fireplace...however the upstairs looks like crap and could've used alot more effort)
(11:50:29 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img695.imageshack.us/img695/8795/kitchenv.jpg
(11:50:29 AM) Cata|Vanette: next
(11:51:34 AM) platypus: guessing that is bina...cant believe he has that awesome carcass
(11:51:40 AM) platypus: this one is definately the winner so far
(11:51:42 AM) Cata|Vanette: nope
(11:51:43 AM) Cata|Vanette: not him ;P
(11:52:55 AM) platypus: Theme: 9, Originality: 8, Overall Appeal: 9 (nothing i haven't seen before, but it looks great the way its presented...not a 10 since its a bit too crowded with items, but otherwise amazing)
(11:56:31 AM) platypus: Theme: 10, Originality: 10, Overall Appeal: 8 (theme is really creative and original, but a few things (such as the hay, potion keg and dyed clothed strewn about) look out of place and unorganized...it wouldve gotten all 10s if not for these few things)
(11:57:00 AM) platypus: that one is my favorite, but i'd say the kitchen was the best organized/well thought out one
(11:57:13 AM) Cata|Vanette: right on
(11:57:38 AM) Cata|Vanette: I enjoy the complexity of the kitchen
NeilDiamond-
(11:31:37 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://i45.tinypic.com/10cw8zs.jpg
(11:33:13 AM) NeilDiamond: Hmm ok
(11:33:51 AM) NeilDiamond: Use of theme Id give it a 9 out of 10
(11:34:19 AM) NeilDiamond: originality, Id give it a 6 out of 10
(11:34:32 AM) NeilDiamond: maybe a bit harsh but dont see anything really new here
(11:38:10 AM) Cata|Vanette: overall appeal
(11:38:15 AM) Cata|Vanette: gogo
(11:39:06 AM) NeilDiamond: ok
(11:39:20 AM) NeilDiamond: overall appeal, Id give a 7 out of 10
(11:39:54 AM) Cata|Vanette: alrighty
(11:39:55 AM) Cata|Vanette: next one!
(11:40:10 AM) NeilDiamond: k give me one sec, buying a mare
(11:40:12 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://sites.google.com/site/khaaans/Humble_Abode.png
(11:40:13 AM) Cata|Vanette: alright
(11:43:26 AM) NeilDiamond: ok
(11:43:54 AM) NeilDiamond: Theme, 5 out of 10
(11:44:12 AM) NeilDiamond: Originality 6 out of 10
(11:44:25 AM) NeilDiamond: Overall appeal 8 out of 10
(11:44:41 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://forum.uosecondage.com/download/file.php?id=3922
(11:44:44 AM) Cata|Vanette: you have to sign in first
(11:44:46 AM) Cata|Vanette: to the forums
(11:44:51 AM) NeilDiamond: k
(11:47:18 AM) Cata|Vanette: did it load?
(11:47:21 AM) Cata|Vanette: if not, ignore it for now
(11:47:30 AM) Cata|Vanette: it's gonna get reuploaded
(11:47:37 AM) Cata|Vanette: (11:46:45 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v610/ ... stairs.jpg
(11:47:37 AM) Cata|Vanette: (11:46:49 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v610/ ... stairs.jpg
(11:47:39 AM) Cata|Vanette: is the next one
(11:47:39 AM) NeilDiamond: Yeah cant access it
(11:49:21 AM) NeilDiamond: ok Theme 6 out of 10
(11:49:30 AM) NeilDiamond: originality 8 out of 10
(11:49:34 AM) NeilDiamond: overall appeal 7 out of 10
11:50:25 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img695.imageshack.us/img695/8795/kitchenv.jpg
(11:50:26 AM) Cata|Vanette: next
(11:52:33 AM) NeilDiamond: Theme a 9 out of 10. Originality 9 out of 10. Overall appeal 9 out of 10
(11:53:28 AM) Cata|Vanette: and last
(11:53:28 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://photos-1.dropbox.com/i/o/W03gVhM ... Ywo2xOBmE4
(11:53:31 AM) Cata|Vanette: for now, anyway
(11:53:55 AM) NeilDiamond: 404 error
(11:53:59 AM) Cata|Vanette: doh
(11:54:00 AM) Cata|Vanette: sec
(11:54:22 AM) Cata|Vanette: i'll reupload
(11:55:34 AM) Cata|Vanette:
http://img693.imageshack.us/img693/1078 ... yjcoq7.jpg
(11:55:36 AM) Cata|Vanette: there
(11:58:14 AM) NeilDiamond: Theme 9 out of 10. Originality 10 out of 10. Overall appeal 9 out of 10
(11:58:20 AM) NeilDiamond: Very cool one