UO Second Age

Voted yes.

C^V and DG have helped each other out and traded in different instances, always with very positive results for both guilds. All the interaction I've had with them has been positive, and they ARE very active.

Two thumbs up.

Very active guild, but they are lacking on the events front. Would like to see more interaction with non-guild-members.

I abstain.

This shard needs new volunteer/counselors not out for their own well being. Would help eliminate the guilds that barely exist (mym/ka) anymore and advocate for DG. I once used a "counselor's help;" and I can almost bet it was Derrik.

I Vote YES!

I'm going to vote no, not to be a killjoy but I believe add-ons should be given to guilds who have actually made a difference to the shard. I know that's not how it usually works but it should be.

Not to take anything away from DG but what have they really offered the shard? Have they run any events of significant note? Have they proven beneficial to the shard as a whole or only to their members and possibly another guild or two? I will give them credit for helping new players and building their numbers, but I don't believe this in and of itself warrants the "gimme stuff" approval that they are asking for.

Maybe if they start running some shard events or provide a legitimate service to the shard then it might be appropriate. I don't feel that just because a large guild asks for stuff that they should be given what they want.

No offense to anyone in DG, it's merely my opinion.

do our opinions even matter ?

Grimm Blackdyrge wrote:I'm going to vote no, not to be a killjoy but I believe add-ons should be given to guilds who have actually made a difference to the shard. I know that's not how it usually works but it should be.

Not to take anything away from DG but what have they really offered the shard? Have they run any events of significant note? Have they proven beneficial to the shard as a whole or only to their members and possibly another guild or two? I will give them credit for helping new players and building their numbers, but I don't believe this in and of itself warrants the "gimme stuff" approval that they are asking for.

Maybe if they start running some shard events or provide a legitimate service to the shard then it might be appropriate. I don't feel that just because a large guild asks for stuff that they should be given what they want.

No offense to anyone in DG, it's merely my opinion.

They help the shard by being very active. I prefer the open field interaction and the RP interaction they have offered to other guilds, any day.

lettuce wrote:do our opinions even matter ?

yes add ons have to be approved by the players

DG does make a difference to the shard.

A few more guilds like them and this would be a more live like shard with better rivalries and more field PVP.

DG is a good example of a guild that doesn't need to do big events to add to the shard, they are always around and always helpful. Everyday is an event!

Mikel123 wrote:Very active guild, but they are lacking on the events front. Would like to see more interaction with non-guild-members.

I abstain.

^ Same here.
I seen other guilds gruel over their add ons.
I won't vote no, but I can't vote yes.
*especially since DG is located exactly where my old tower and other properties fell

No seriously, recruiting alot of people can be done by anyone. We need a feel for DG in either events or in stories posted on forums at the very least.

"Other people posting on interactions with DG do not count"

I vote yes. DG contributes a lot to the server which is badly needed, and I feel they are deserving of add ons.

However:

1) I think DG should come up with a name for their town.

2) I think DG should first meet all the requirements for town add ons; mainly by running shard-wide events.
viewtopic.php?f=9&t=6439

Panthor the Hated wrote:DG is a good example of a guild that doesn't need to do big events to add to the shard, they are always around and always helpful. Everyday is an event!

+1

dren wrote:I vote yes. DG contributes a lot to the server which is badly needed, and I feel they are deserving of add ons.

However:

1) I think DG should come up with a name for their town.

2) I think DG should first meet all the requirements for town add ons; mainly by running shard-wide events.
viewtopic.php?f=9&t=6439

Its looking to be very likely that we will dub our town "Moonstone Bay"

DG has always had IL's support amongst many other guilds, there isn't a more deserving guild around.

Good luck DG,